Analysis on the Inevitability of the tragedy of R & J
Abstract: There are various causes that result in the love tragedy between R & J. Many clues in the story has paved for their tragedy and hinted that the ending of their love story would be romantic but sad. I will analyses the inevitability of their love tragedy from three aspects.
1. Social background——The tragedy is the inevitability result of the development of social background.
We say that a literature accomplished in a special historical period must have its own distinct features of time. R & J is written in the late 16th century, the Renaissance began to sprout and feudalism in England was falling. Shakespeare put the social background of that time into his work, so R & J are the representatives of rising bourgeois who living in the Renaissance period and influenced by the Humanism.
As the spirit core of the Renaissance period, the Humanism emphasizes to care for people and take people as the main body. It advocates tolerant, promotes individuality liberation, pursuits the real love in life, pursuits the freedom and equality, opposes hierarchy, advocates rational, against feudalism and backward feudal idea. Because under the deep influence of this thought, R & J still pursuit their love bravely after knowing the identity of each other, regardless of the hared of the feudal family and the discourage of friends. They abandon medieval asceticism to pursuit a true love with a combination of spirit and flesh tenaciously. However, the Humanism of Renaissance period and Feudalism are irreconcilable contradiction, which leads to R & J’s love was destined to become a victim of ideological progress and social development.
2. The family contraction
The opening poem said that:
Two households, both alike in dignity,
In fair Verona, where we lay our scene,
In fair Verona, where we lay our scene,
From ancient grudge break to new mutiny,
Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean.
From forth the fatal loins of these two foes
A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their life;
Whole misadventured piteous overthrows
Do with their death bury their parents' strife.
Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean.
From forth the fatal loins of these two foes
A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their life;
Whole misadventured piteous overthrows
Do with their death bury their parents' strife.
Thus it can be seen that the feudal aristocracy Montague and Capulet family had have a deep hatred and bitterness, it represents the competing for feudal force which late from the middle age, meanwhile, it also represents the old rotten cannot coordinate the contradiction between feudalism thought itself. But their children fell in love with each other. The conflict between love and hate, it’s the inevitable result of the struggle between humanism thought and inevitable thought. This is bedding for the bed ending of the love tragedy of R & J.
3. The character of inevitability
I only analyses the personal character of the two main roles.
Romeo and Juliet their characters have dual nature.
Romeo is gentle, warm and kind. He has a strong pursuit of freedom and true love. But on the other hand, he is not mature and rational enough, so he finally made his love a great disaster just in order to revenge for his friend. He doesn’t have a independent idea but in the hope of the priest. His blind of love and the pursuit of the faith let him underestimated the two feudal family, which eventually led to their death.
And Juliet is naïve, lively, rich rational, brave and intelligent composed. But she was too weak and naive, facing to his father's threat, she showed the helpless and made the same choice to Romeo, that is asking the priest for help. She is a typical idealist, wrongly estimated the gap between ideal and reality. She thought of things too simple, eventually led to the tragedy of love.
So, the two characters personality of the main roles showed that the emerging bourgeoisie is weak and compromising when faced to feudal forces. So it does, their brave but immature love is doomed to failure.
So, the two characters personality of the main roles showed that the emerging bourgeoisie is weak and compromising when faced to feudal forces. So it does, their brave but immature love is doomed to failure.
Reference thesis: 浅析罗密欧与朱丽叶爱情悲剧的必然性 - 豆丁网
URL: www.docin/p-709878751.html
Bibliography6H!u"RJ s EF-Ne:
:a tI0wg#c
pY【1】【2】【3】钱海水«罗密欧与朱丽叶.哈姆雷特»,北京科学技术出版社,2007,P1. P6.P26.
E`;s-?n(C#P
dF%p【4】东方兰.论莎士比亚的《冬天的故事》[J].文学研究,1940,
o3E.]Vph%y!^`*PG7R【5】贺祥麟.莎士比亚[M].沈阳:辽宁人民出版社,1984.
9d
FXCv3_-Qp【6】矫福军; 莎士比亚悲剧的思想意蕴 [D];吉林大学; 2004年教育论文网7[8yS3HL*LM
【7】李伟民; 莎士比亚研究——构筑起心灵的家园——兼评张冲的《莎士比亚专题研究》 [J];外语研究; 2007年02期 教育论文网 H/w:B
`muC7GS
:a tI0wg#c
pY【1】【2】【3】钱海水«罗密欧与朱丽叶.哈姆雷特»,北京科学技术出版社,2007,P1. P6.P26.
E`;s-?n(C#P
dF%p【4】东方兰.论莎士比亚的《冬天的故事》[J].文学研究,1940,
o3E.]Vph%y!^`*PG7R【5】贺祥麟.莎士比亚[M].沈阳:辽宁人民出版社,1984.
9d
FXCv3_-Qp【6】矫福军; 莎士比亚悲剧的思想意蕴 [D];吉林大学; 2004年教育论文网7[8yS3HL*LM
【7】李伟民; 莎士比亚研究——构筑起心灵的家园——兼评张冲的《莎士比亚专题研究》 [J];外语研究; 2007年02期 教育论文网 H/w:B
`muC7GS
【8】亢西民.莎士比亚戏剧赏析辞典[Z].太原:山西教育出版社,1992..
S;N+km3k0^){D【9】肖四新; 莎士比亚悲剧的宗教解读 [J];三峡大学学报(人文社会科学版); 2004年05期
H1B5`v,seJE【10】再说莎士比亚何以成为莎士比亚 [J];外国文学评论; 2005年03期; 154-155
1thNyq"h:h"V【11】卞之琳; 了与不了:莎士比亚悲剧研究纪程——《莎士比亚悲剧论痕》前言[J]; 外国文学评论; 1987年01期; 107-110 教育论文网H8x4S3z O
S;N+km3k0^){D【9】肖四新; 莎士比亚悲剧的宗教解读 [J];三峡大学学报(人文社会科学版); 2004年05期
H1B5`v,seJE【10】再说莎士比亚何以成为莎士比亚 [J];外国文学评论; 2005年03期; 154-155
1thNyq"h:h"V【11】卞之琳; 了与不了:莎士比亚悲剧研究纪程——《莎士比亚悲剧论痕》前言[J]; 外国文学评论; 1987年01期; 107-110 教育论文网H8x4S3z O
The similarity between The Flea and To His Coy Mistress
At first, both Andrew Marvel and John Donne are the metaphysical poets. John Donne is the representative of metaphysical poetry in the seventeen century in Britain. And Marvel also is a metaphysical poet in the English Renaissance. So, they are all influenced by humanism and metaphysical school.
发布评论